Paul here is the picture of the Kops from the Masquers short, also the 1912 photo that is referenced....I'm sure you have checked this but just in case I searched through the Masquers 1975 50th anniversary book and there was no mention of Arbuckle in reference to "stout" there was a piece about him appearing in one of their live shows in 1925 but that was it. I checked the holdings at my new job at USC and we didn't have the film, but we did have BRIDE'S BEREAVEMENT (aka The Snake in the Grass) and TWO LIPS AND JULEPS that aren't on the Encore set.
OH and I'm thinking the guy to the right in the Jimmie Adams photo is James Gleason.

- kops1931.jpg (198.39 KiB) Viewed 747 times

- kops1912.jpg (130.9 KiB) Viewed 748 times