SilentComedyMafia.com

From the Chelsea Rialto Studios, which always comes up with rare stuff, here's the original release trailer for Harold Lloyd's The Cat's Paw. I don't know whether it was originally released in an amber tint, or if this is just an artifact of the transfer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YhLQGzenkcQ

Just my humble opinion: I know MOVIE CRAZY has its fans, but for me, THE CAT'S PAW provides a tantalizing glimpse of the Harold Lloyd that could have been. This characterization was a good fit for the now-mature (and somewhat prissy-sounding) Lloyd, who abandoned his boyish go-getter far too late. SPEAK EASILY (yet another Kelland story) was a poor fit for Keaton, but I think Lloyd could have pulled it off better. Even Lloyd's later films, flawed though they may be, at least attempted to dismiss the eager beaver for a more settled career man type. With better guidance, he might extended his career, albeit it not on the Big Three level he'd enjoyed through the Twenties.

I completely agree William, I have always said THE CATS PAW is the best of Lloyd's talkies, and that it points a way, if not necessarily THE way, Lloyd could and should have changed his character as he aged and continued on with more success than he did. Lloyd should have let his character become a family or at least married-man in middle age, or let his rich-guy character be brought low by the Depression and got his way out of it. I think Lloyd was too rich, too insulated and too in-control for someone he might listen to to point him in the right direction, he knew something was wrong, and the eccentric fish out of water was as far as he was willing to go to change.

RICHARD M ROBERTS

This trailer didn't do Lloyd any favors. In every shot, he is completely inert except for his prissy half-smile. The trailer's not-so-subtle message is, "yes, its Harold Lloyd, but LOOK AT THE GREAT SUPPORTING CAST!!!"