Thanks for the help. It's definitely not Helene Costello. She was the female lead, and I have quite a few stills with her and Griffith.
Raymond Griffith and Helene Costello
Raymond Griffith, unknown, Helene Costello and Bryant Washburn.
The plot of the film is that Griffith is going to get married to Costello, although before the wedding he finds out that she is going to marry him on a bet, not that she actually loves him. So he vows to marry the next woman that he meets instead, and it's Natalie Kingston. Unfortunately, she's already married.